Wrong Question

Reading MSNBC – Does Your iPod Play Favorites? But just about everyone who has an iPod has wondered […]

Reading MSNBC – Does Your iPod Play Favorites?

But just about everyone who has an iPod has wondered how random the iPod shuffle function really is. From the day I loaded up my first Pod, it was as if the little devil liked to play favorites.

I have to ask– do you really want true randomness? Because I don’t. I want my shuffle to learn. I want it to notice when I fast forward in the first ten seconds of a song, and when I fast forward toward the end, or through the rest of the album. I want it to read the tempo and genre,a nd make decent mixes for me. I want it to stop putting chapter five of Art of War between Bireli Langrene and Abba.

The fetishization of true randomness is such a engineering thing to do. True serendipity comes from designing a user experience not calculating an abstract one, and a great algorithm comes from studying humans, not studying math.

1 Comment

Add Yours
  1. 1
    every breath death defying

    Shuffling the “Wrong Question”

    Christina has suggested that some of the media and user focus around the true randomness of the iPod/iTunes’ shuffle is misplaced. Instead of true mathematical randomness, it should be based on tempo, genre, and user behavior (such as fast-forwarding)….

Comments are closed.